Please help me to prove the problem! and show all your work A function f : D rig
ID: 2963177 • Letter: P
Question
Please help me to prove the problem! and show all your work
Explanation / Answer
f(x) is monotonically increasing
x1=r
x2=f(x1)
x3=f(x2)
There are 3 possibilities:
1. x2>x1
=> f(x2)>=f(x1) //reason is f is monotonically increasing function
=> x3>=x2
2. x2<x1
=> f(x2)<=f(x1) //reason is f is monotonically increasing function
=> x3<=x2
3. x2=x1
=> f(x2)=f(x1)
=> x3=x2
Suppose we are given:
xk
x(k+1)=f(xk)
x(k+2)=f(x(k+1)
There are 3 possibilities:
1. x(k+1)>xk
=> f(x(k+1))>=f(xk) //reason is f is monotonically increasing function
=> x(k+2)>=x(k+1)
2. x(k+1)<xk
=> f(x(k+1))<=f(xk) //reason is f is monotonically increasing function
=> x(k+2)<=x(k+1)
3. x(k+1)=xk
=> f(x(k+1))=f(xk)
=> x(k+2)=x(k+1)
So if x2> x1 => x3>x2 => x4>x3 .........=>x(k+1) > xk ....
As k->infinity, xk->infinity
So if x2<x1 => x3<x2 => x4<x3 .........=>x(k+1) < xk ....
As k->infinity, xk->negative infinity
So if x2= x1 => x3=x2 => x4=x3 .........=>x(k+1) =xk....
As k->infinity, xk->x1
SO xn either converges to positive infinity or negative infinity or a constant c = x1=r
A set D is called dense subset of R if for any x in R, within every neighbourhood of x there exists an element of D.
Suppose f(x) is not 1 for all x in R.
Suppose f(x)=some k not equal to 1
Within a small neighbourhood of x (x-a,x+a), there exists a y such that y is in D.
we know that f(y)=1
As a->0, (x-a,x+a)->x
Even in such a small neighbourhood, there exists a y such that y is in D and f(y)=1
But f(x)=k not equal to 1
This means that the function is not continuous at x
Which is a contradiction
So f(x) is 1 for all x in R