Scenario You are a former Navy officer and fighter pilot who is ✓ Solved

You are a former Navy officer and fighter pilot who is now the controller of a division of TransGlobal Airlines, which utilizes a fleet of corporate jets for charter at several airports in the southeast part of the United States. Your division’s private charter clients include several Fortune 500 companies in the region. The Chief Financial Officer (CFO) has informed you that the company is considering the acquisition of two smaller aviation firms in the Caribbean specializing in chartered flights for luxury vacations using light aircraft (60 passengers or less). The CFO has tasked you with assessing the organizational benefits of acquiring these aviation firms. The CFO intends to develop a new business plan for the organization if your analysis recommends moving forward with the acquisition.

After an initial assessment, the company has shortlisted two airlines they want to examine further for acquisition. To understand all aspects of the two airlines under consideration, you have visited each proposed site to assess their performance. The assessment includes creating and analyzing a balanced scorecard for each airline with all four components—financial, internal processes, customers/market, and learning and growth—that will impact the acquisition. In this milestone, you will use the given information to create balanced scorecards for Company A and Company B.

Use the Basic Balanced Scorecard Template to create a balanced scorecard for each company. Specifically, you must address the following criteria:

  • A. Use the data given in Company A Information and Company A Financials to create a balanced scorecard for Company A. The balanced scorecard should highlight key performance indicators, such as net profit, annual growth, and market share, and include the four components:

    • a. Financial: Complete the financial section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

    • b. Internal Processes: Complete the internal processes section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

    • c. Customers/Market: Complete the customers/market section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

    • d. Learning and Growth: Complete the learning and growth section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

  • B. Use the data given in Company B Information and Company B Financials to create a balanced scorecard for Company B. The balanced scorecard should highlight key performance indicators, such as net profit, annual growth, and market share, and include the four components:

    • a. Financial: Complete the financial section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

    • b. Internal Processes: Complete the internal processes section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

    • c. Customers/Market: Complete the customers/market section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

    • d. Learning and Growth: Complete the learning and growth section of the balanced scorecard template, identifying two of the most relevant key performance indicators. Explain your rationale for the KPIs chosen, with an explanation of the cause-and-effect relationship between the chosen KPIs.

Submission: Submit two completed Excel spreadsheets using the provided template.

Paper For Above Instructions

In the evaluation of potential acquisitions of Company A and Company B, the balanced scorecard (BSC) approach is integral to assessing the organizational benefits each company brings to TransGlobal Airlines. The BSC provides a structured means of translating an organization’s strategic objectives into a set of operational objectives across four perspectives: financial, internal processes, customers/market, and learning and growth. Each category will feature key performance indicators (KPIs) relevant to the assessment of both companies’ potential value.

Balanced Scorecard for Company A

Financial Perspective

The financial section of Company A’s balanced scorecard will feature the following KPIs: net profit margin and return on investment (ROI). The net profit margin indicates the percentage of revenue that translates into profits after all expenses are deducted. This KPI is vital as it directly reflects the company’s financial health and profitability, crucial in determining whether the acquisition would enhance TransGlobal’s bottom line.

ROI shows how effectively the firm utilizes its capital and investments. A higher ROI signifies a company is efficiently generating income relative to its costs. Given the potential costs associated with an acquisition, investors and stakeholders will be keen to understand how well Company A can deliver returns, reinforcing its attractiveness as an acquisition target.

Internal Processes Perspective

For internal processes, we recognize operational efficiency and the rate of innovation as central KPIs. The operational efficiency KPI considers metrics such as average turnaround time for flights and maintenance costs. Enhancing operational efficiency can lead to reduced costs and improved customer satisfaction, integral elements for a successful luxury charter service.

Meanwhile, the rate of innovation KPI reflects how adaptable the company is in implementing new technologies or improving services. In the competitive charter flight industry, being innovative can set a company apart from competitors, enhancing its market share and appealing to affluent clients.

Customers/Market Perspective

The customers/market section will feature customer satisfaction scores and market share growth as KPIs. Customer satisfaction is pivotal in the luxury travel industry; it influences repeat business and brand loyalty. High satisfaction scores can result in referrals and a strong reputation, vital for a company in the service sector.

Market share growth indicates the company’s competitiveness within the industry. Acquiring a business with a growing market share can position TransGlobal more favorably against competitors, thus growing overall revenues.

Learning and Growth Perspective

In the learning and growth area, employee training and development metrics and technology adoption rates will feature as key indicators. Investment in employee training directly correlates with service quality, influencing customer satisfaction and firm reputation. It’s essential for Company A to remain competitive with a well-trained workforce.

The rate of technology adoption illustrates the company’s commitment to staying current amidst rapidly evolving industry standards, allowing for improved operational capabilities and customer engagement.

Balanced Scorecard for Company B

Financial Perspective

The financial KPIs for Company B will include revenue growth rate and EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, and Amortization). Revenue growth rate serves to demonstrate how well the company expands its topline, which is critical for evaluating potential future earnings potential for TransGlobal.

EBITDA is a metric often regarded as a proxy for operational profitability, providing insights into the core earnings of the company. A strong EBITDA will indicate the potential for healthy cash flows post-acquisition.

Internal Processes Perspective

For internal processes, key efficiency ratios and production cycle times will be scrutinized. Efficiency ratios such as load factor (the percentage of available seating capacity that is filled with passengers) are crucial indicators for assessing operational performance. A high load factor means the airline is efficiently utilizing its fleet.

Production cycle times also highlight the company’s ability to manage operations efficiently; shorter cycle times could provide quicker service to clients and potentially enhance profitability.

Customers/Market Perspective

The critical customer-related KPIs for Company B will be client retention rates and brand recognition scores. Client retention rate is essential in the luxury market; retaining high-value clients minimizes marketing costs and stabilizes revenues.

Brand recognition is important for attracting new clientele, particularly among businesses seeking luxury charter services. A well-recognized brand may command higher prices and generate more interest in services compared to lesser-known competitors.

Learning and Growth Perspective

Company B’s learning and growth metrics will include staff turnover rates and innovation output. A low staff turnover rate suggests employees are engaged and satisfied, contributing to higher service levels and overall performance.

Innovation output will measure the number and success rate of new initiatives or offerings, necessary for staying competitive within the luxury market.

Conclusion

The balanced scorecards for Companies A and B provide a comprehensive framework for assessing their suitability for acquisition by TransGlobal Airlines. Through careful analysis of the KPIs outlined, insights can be drawn to guide strategic decisions and ensure an alignment with the broader organizational objectives of enhancing operational efficiency and market presence in the luxury aviation sector.

References

  • Kaplan, R.S., & Norton, D.P. (1996). The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action. Harvard Business Review Press.

  • Neely, A. (2002). Business Performance Measurement: Unifying Theory and Integrating Practice. Cambridge University Press.

  • Ittner, C.D., & Larcker, D.F. (2003). Coming Up Short on Nonfinancial Performance Measurement. Harvard Business Review, 81(11), 88-95.

  • Paranjape, B., & Natt, S. (2011). Balanced Scorecard in enhancing organizational performance: an exploratory case study. International Journal of Business Performance Management.

  • Kumar, V., & Sethi, R. (2016). Strategic Approaches to Success: Balanced Scorecard for Performance Management. International Journal of Managing Value and Supply Chains, 7(2), 1-12.

  • Kaplan, R.S. (2009). Conceptual Foundations of the Balanced Scorecard. Harvard Business School.

  • Berrah, L. (2019). Role of Balanced Scorecard in Organizations: A Case Study. International Journal of Business and Management.

  • Gumbus, A., & Lussier, R.N. (2006). Business Plans for New Ventures: A Review of the Literature. International Journal of Business and Management.

  • Ittner, C.D., & Larcker, D.F. (2001). Assessing Empirical Research in Managerial Accounting: A Value-Based Management Perspective. Accounting, Organizations and Society, 26(8), 763-779.

  • Young, S.D. (2013). A Balanced Scorecard for the Acceleration of Organizational Learning. Journal of Organizational Learning and Leadership.