Unit III Comparative Criminal Justice Theories Move your cursor ✓ Solved

Discuss the key concepts and theories in comparative criminal justice.

Paper For Above Instructions

The field of comparative criminal justice examines the differences and similarities between various legal systems, focusing on how law and order are maintained across different cultures and jurisdictions. This paper explores key concepts and theories, including Strain Theory, Broken Windows Theory, and the impact of globalization on policing, providing insights into how these theories shape the practice of justice globally.

Strain Theory

Strain Theory, formulated by Robert K. Merton in 1938, posits that societal structures can pressure citizens to commit crimes. According to Merton, when individuals feel disconnected from societal goals—such as financial success or social status—they may resort to deviant behavior as a means of coping with the pressure of their environment (Merton, 1938). This theory is critical in understanding crime within different cultural contexts and has implications for developing crime prevention strategies.

The video accompanying this theory provides a better perspective on how societal expectations can lead to criminal behavior, particularly in marginalized communities where opportunities to achieve these goals are limited (ShortCuts TV, 2018).

Broken Windows Theory

Broken Windows Theory suggests that maintaining and monitoring urban environments to prevent small crimes, such as vandalism and public disorder, can create an atmosphere of order and lawfulness. This theory is often associated with the zero-tolerance philosophy of law enforcement, which asserts that laws must be enforced consistently, regardless of severity (Pakes, 2019). This approach has been both praised for reducing crime rates in some urban areas and criticized for leading to over-policing and discriminatory practices. The balance between order and justice is vital when applying this theory across different jurisdictions.

Globalization and Policing

Globalization has dramatically influenced crime and policing. Transnational policing has emerged as a response to the rapid increase in international criminal activities, including terrorism and human trafficking. This aspect of policing highlights the significance of international cooperation in law enforcement efforts. The speed of communication and the establishment of networked societies have facilitated cross-border crimes, prompting law enforcement agencies to collaborate more closely (Daisymay11, n.d.).

At a macro level, transnational policing is governed by conventions and treaties, such as the United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime, which provides a legal framework for combating organized crime internationally (United Nations General Assembly, 2001). On a micro level, law enforcement encounters are influenced by organizations like INTERPOL, which allows jurisdictions from different countries to work together effectively in investigations (Hafakot, n.d.).

Comparative Criminology

Comparative criminology extends the study of crime to an international perspective, examining how different cultures and legal systems approach law enforcement, punishment, and rehabilitation. It is essential to understand that crime does not occur in a vacuum; instead, it is culturally and socially constructed. Analyzing crime through a comparative lens provides deeper insights into how societal values and legal frameworks shape criminal behavior and societal responses to it.

This interdisciplinary field contributes to the development of more effective crime prevention strategies by leveraging successful practices and learning from the failures of various criminal justice systems around the world.

Conclusion

In conclusion, comparative criminal justice theories such as Strain Theory and Broken Windows Theory, alongside the influence of globalization, shape how crimes are viewed and managed across different societies. Understanding these concepts offers valuable perspectives that can enhance global collaboration in law enforcement and contribute to the development of more equitable and effective justice systems. As we navigate an increasingly interconnected world, the need for collaborative approaches to crime prevention and law enforcement has never been more critical.

References

  • Daisymay11. (n.d.). French customs border control [Photograph]. Retrieved from -photo-french-customs-border-control-eurostar-train-channel-tunnel-image

  • Hafakot. (n.d.). INTERPOL – International concept [Photograph]. Retrieved from illustration-interpol-title-ground-police-arena-interpol-international-concept-image

  • Merton, R. K. (1938). Social structure and anomie. American Sociological Review, 3(5), 672. Retrieved from direct=true&db=edsjsr&AN=edsjsr.&site=eds-live&scope=site

  • Pakes, F. (2019). Comparative criminal justice (4th ed.). New York, NY: Routledge.

  • ShortCuts TV (Producer). (2018). Strain theory (Segment 1 of 4) [Video file]. Retrieved from PortalPlaylists.aspx?wID=273866&xtid=154658&loid=508184

  • United Nations General Assembly. (2001). United Nations Convention Against Transnational Organized Crime [Illustration]. Retrieved from Transnational_Organized_Crime.djvu

  • Additional source 1 (Year). Title. Publisher. DOI/URL

  • Additional source 2 (Year). Title. Publisher. DOI/URL

  • Additional source 3 (Year). Title. Publisher. DOI/URL

  • Additional source 4 (Year). Title. Publisher. DOI/URL