Purdue Gltbal Uiiivf Sitycase Study Analysiswhat Is A Case Studya ✓ Solved

PURDUE GL~t,BAL U'IIIVF SITY Case Study Analysis What is a Case Study? A case study is a narrative used to help students practice real-life analysis and communication skills. It is a learning tool. It provides readers with “enough detail…to understand the nature and scope of the problem, and…serve as a springboard for discussion and learning†(O’Rourke, 2007, p. 391).

A case study differs from a case history in that a history summarizes events that already took place, and usually include the manager’s response to the situation (O’Rourke, 2007). This resource provides you with information about how to analyze a case study and write up your analysis in a professional report, letter, or memo format. Analyzing a Case Study What exactly does it mean to analyze a case study? Analysis means you look at a situation from various angles paying attention to even the smallest details, as it is usually details that lead you to understanding a situation to its fullest and help you make effective decisions. To analyze a case study, follow these basic guidelines: •Read carefully •Identify major issues •Identify alternative courses of action •Recommend a course of action •Provide a rationale for your decision Read Carefully Every case study you encounter will be different.

Generally, there is no set format or formula for how these documents are written (except that, normally, they are written chronologically), so it is important that you pay attention to all of the details. Read slowly and carefully, taking notes or annotating the document. If appendices are included, read those carefully too, as the smallest detail can make a difference in what you determine is the best course of action. Read tables and figures carefully, and interpret them in relation to the information contained in the case study. Identify Major Issues Your main job when analyzing a case study is to learn to identify major issues of concern for you or your company.

Do not focus on minor issues (issues that have no bearing on the case, such as personal biases or preferences), but stay focused on PURDUE GL~t,BAL U'IIIVF SITY major issues, such as actions or decisions that affect other people, the company’s financial bottom line, or a company’s reputation. It is important to clarify here that details are not minor issues. Details are individual instances of action, but details can provide evidence for how a major issue is being affected. For instance, if someone is consistently sending out poorly written letters with misspellings and grammar errors to clients, that’s a detail; however, that detail is evidence that the company’s reputation is at stake. Once you identify major issues, look at how they are being presented or compromised in the case study so that you have a basis for how to effectively deal with the situation and solve the problem.

Typically, case studies are written in chronological order, so it may take several readings to identify major issues correctly (O’Rourke, 2007) and from various perspectives. Identify Alternative Courses of Action This is where you put your course knowledge to work. What have you learned about how to solve certain issues through your course material and discussions? To identify an appropriate course of action, or identify several ways to deal with a situation, you will apply what you have learned to your understanding of the case study and the major issues you have already identified. This is also where you have to read your case study questions carefully and be sure to answer them according to your professor’s guidelines.

The information you provide in this section of a case study analysis should all be based on professional knowledge and information gleaned from your courses. Recommend a Course of Action A recommendation is a plan for implementing a certain course of action that you deem to be the most advantageous. Choose from one course of action that you identified in the earlier section and set forth the details for how to put this decision into action. Who needs to do what, when, where, and how? No one can read your mind, so be detailed and precise in your description on the execution of your recommendation.

Provide a Rationale for Your Decision It’s one thing to recommend a course of action and even detail out the plan you have in mind, but your readers will not be thoroughly convinced that it is the right decision until you offer them your rationale for your decision. What this means is that you provide them with reasons for the conclusions you have drawn, including any additional or outside research you have conducted to substantiate your decision. Readers want to know why and how you came to the decision you have regarding the situation in the case study. PURDUE GL~t,BAL U'IIIVF SITY References O’Rourke, James S. (2007). Management communication: A case-analysis approach.

Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson/Prentice Hall. Purdue University Global Writing Center (2019). Case study analysis. Retrieved from CMGT Architectural Planning & Design Management Construction Drawings Why plan reading is important! Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Architectural Drawings • Show the materials and construction process used to make a structure • Drawings specify: – Interior and exterior materials – Requirements for structural components – Windows, doors, insulation, and finishes • Make up the core of the drawing set on a project • Typically classified with the prefix A Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Floor Plans • Show the building layout • Drawn to scale (usually 1/4 = 1ï‚¢-0) • Generated by making a cut about 4ï‚¢ above finished floor • Serve as a reference for other types of drawings: – Mechanical plans – Plumbing plans – Electrical plans Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Floor Plans (Cont.) (CR architecture + design) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Main Floor Plan Example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Upper Floor Plan Example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Lower Floor Plan Example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Wall Representation Practices • Exterior walls thicker than interior walls, • Exterior and interior walls the same thickness, or • Walls drawn at the exact thickness of construction materials Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Exterior Walls • Main floor plan example • Lower floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Wall Shading • None • Dark • Light • Closely spaced thin lines • Wood grain effect • Color Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Partial Walls • Room dividers • Guardrails • Normally at least a 36" (915 mm) high • Specifications noted • May be shaded Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Door Symbols • Exterior doors include a sill shown on the outside of the house • Interior doors do not display a sill • Normally at least 3" (75 mm) of construction materials where the door swings against the wall • Main floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Door Symbols • Pocket • Bipass • Bifold • Sliding glass • Main floor plan example • Upper floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Door Symbols • Double-entry • French • Double-acting Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Door Symbols • Dutch • Accordion • Overhead garage Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Window Symbols • Include a sill on the outside and inside • Type and size is noted on the floor plan or in the window schedule • Lower floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Window Symbols • Horizontal sliding • Casement • Double-hung Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Window Symbols • Awning • Hopper • Jalousie Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Window Symbols • Fixed • Bay • Garden Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Schedules • List of materials or products required in a structure • Specify types, sizes, and number of items required • A symbol or tag identifies each item in both the schedule and drawing • Types of schedules: – Door – Window – Finish Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Schedules (Cont.) (CR architecture + design) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Skylights • Add additional daylight in a room • Allow natural light to enter an interior room • Upper floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Schedules • Doors • Windows • Appliances • Materials • Fixtures • Hardware • Finishes Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Schedules • Lower floor plan example • Alternative schedule key method Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Door and Window Labels • Simplified (shown) • Manufactures catalog number Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Vendors’ Specifications • Door catalog • Window catalog • Construction details • Product specifications Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Kitchen Cabinets, Fixtures, and Appliances Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Bathroom Cabinets and Fixtures • Vanity • Main floor plan example • Upper floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Utility Rooms • Clothes washer and dryer • Laundry tray • Ironing board • Furnace • Hot-water heater • Main floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Wardrobes and Closets • Upper floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Finish Material Identification • None • Notes • Characteristic symbols • Finish schedule Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Structural Materials Identification • Notes • Symbols Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Stairs on Floor Plans Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Stairs on Floor Plans Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Steps to Sunken and Raised Rooms • One or more steps required • Steps noted with an arrow • Required handrails and guardrails shown Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Fireplaces • Masonry • Wood frame • Steel fireboxes • Zero clearance Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Wood Storage and Cleanout Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Additional Fireplace Items • Combustion air • Gas-burning fireplace • Built-in masonry barbecue • Main floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Multilevel Fireplaces • Fireplace can be placed at each floor • Flues of all stacked fireplaces to extend to the top of the chimney • Main floor plan example • Upper floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Solid Fuel-Burning Appliances • Airtight stoves • Freestanding fireplaces • Fireplace stoves • Room heaters • Zero-clearance fireplaces • Antique stoves • Fireplace inserts Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Room Titles • Main floor plan example Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Other Floor Plan Symbols • Hose bibb • Concrete slab – Patios – Walks – Garages – Driveways Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Other Floor Plan Symbols • Attic and crawl space access • Floor drains • Cross section symbol (shown) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Floor Plans (Cont.) • Other types of drawings fall under the classification of floor plans: – Demolition plans – Enlarged plans – Reflected ceiling plans – Floor finish plans – Overview plans Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Elevations • Show the vertical layout of the building • Can be either interior or exterior views • Show the appearance of the building • Define construction materials, elevation marks, and section cuts • One drawing for each face of a building – Usually identified by compass direction Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Elevations (Cont.) (CR architecture + design) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Types of Elevations • Exterior: – Show doors, windows, gutters, and roof lines – Indicate building materials, such as siding – Show underground features with hidden lines • Interior: – Used for cabinets, bathroom layouts, or window walls – Used when a vertical surface has complex details Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Types of Elevations (Cont.) (CR architecture + design) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Sections • Used to clarify construction of a particular item – Wall – Roof – Chimney • Drawn at a larger scale to show complete information • Taken from a plan or elevation drawing • Identified by locating a section cutting plane Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc.

Building Sections (CR architecture + design) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Detail Sections • Show a small portion of a building to clarify construction • Made at a larger scale • May be placed on same sheet as corresponding plan or elevation (CR architecture + design) Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Glossary • Cleanout (C.O. or CO) – A small door in the floor of the fireplace firebox that allows ashes to be dumped into a hollow cavity built into the fireplace below the floor. • Combustion air – Outside air supplied in sufficient quantity for fuel combustion. • Concrete – A building material made from cement, sand, gravel, and water.

Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Glossary • Drywall – An interior wall covering, also known as gypsum, installed in large sheets made from gypsum board. Gypsum is a mineral consisting of hydrous calcium sulfate that is used in making drywall. • Flue – A heat-resistant, incombustible enclosed passageway in a chimney that carries combustion products from the fireplace. • Framing – The process of creating the framework of the building, usually using wood or steel construction members. Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Glossary • Guardrails – Partitions used for safety on balconies, lofts, stairs, and decks that are over 30" (760 mm) above the next lower level. • Hose bibb – An outdoor water faucet to which a garden hose can be attached. • Masonry – The building of structures from individual units laid and bound together by mortar. • Schedules – Charts of specific items keyed to numbered symbols used on the floor plan.

Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Glossary • Sill – A shelf or slab of stone, wood, or metal at the foot of a door or window. • Studs – The vertical construction members used for framing walls and partitions. • Vanity – Typically, a bathroom cabinet containing a sink with a mirror above; can be any length depending on the space available. Permission granted to reproduce for educational use only.© Goodheart-Willcox Co., Inc. Glossary • Veneer – A thin surface layer of masonry applied to the exterior of a wood-framed wall. • Zero clearance – Insulated fireplace units made of steel that can be used with wood-framed chimneys. 4/29/2020 Sample Content Topic 1/2 Lien Impact on the Buying Process Overview: There are several types of liens that can affect the sale and/or use of a property.

In this assignment you will analyze a scenario in which clients are deterred from a home purchase because of a lien. Read the scenario and then address all the checklist items to develop a solution to the clients’ real estate purchase problem. The following Course Outcome is assessed in this assignment: MT432-2: Develop a solution to a real estate legal problem. Scenario (fictional): Myra and Abe want to buy a second home so they can vacation there as well as eventually retire to the area along the shore of Maine. They currently own a home in Boston, Massachusetts.

They were having some renovation work done on their Boston home, adding on a glassed-in porch. The work was done by Boston Sun Construction Company under a signed contract with the owners to pay ,000 in four installments when the work was 25% completed, 50% completed, 75% completed, and 100% completed in mid-October. But as they neared completion, the agreed upon deposit of three-quarters of the costs had not been paid, only half. The construction company sent them repeated bills to which they did not respond in the month of August. At that time, Myra and Abe were up in Maine enjoying their vacation and looking at properties.

Although the owner of Boston Sun Construction called several times, neither Abe nor Myra answered the calls, thinking all was well. Now Boston Sun Construction Co. has halted construction at the Boston home and put a mechanic’s lien on their home. Assignment Details 4/29/2020 Sample Content Topic 2/2 In the interim, Myra and Abe applied for a mortgage for a second home they found in Maine. But to their dismay, their mortgage was declined because of the mechanic’s lien. Now they are suing Boston Sun Construction Co. for damages since they have lost the option on the home in Maine that they wanted.

Checklist: Provide a summary analysis of the case and the facts. Describe the problem and what should have been done to prevent the problem. Research Boston, Massachusetts’ mechanic’s lien laws. Analyze the legal considerations regarding the mechanic’s lien. Determine how this will be resolved in your opinion based on precedence and the real estate law in your text and explain why.

Decide who will be entitled to what amount and why. Respond in a minimum of 600-word analysis with additional title and reference pages in APA format. After checking the spelling and grammar, submit your response and to the Unit 3 Assignment Dropbox. Access the Unit 3 Assignment grading rubric. Disclaimer: The organization and characters depicted in this exercise are fictional. Any resemblance to real organizations or individuals is purely coincidental.

Paper for above instructions

Introduction

The case of Myra and Abe presents a complex situation involving a mechanic’s lien that has significant financial implications. As they attempt to purchase a second home in Maine, their mortgage application has been denied due to the outstanding lien placed by Boston Sun Construction Company on their primary residence in Boston. This analysis will explore the facts of the case, the origins of the problem, relevant Massachusetts mechanic's lien laws, and potential resolutions based on existing legal precedents.

Summary Analysis of the Case and Facts

Myra and Abe recently undertook renovation work at their Boston home, contracted with Boston Sun Construction Company for the construction of a glassed-in porch valued at ,000. The agreement stipulated payments to be made in four installments, which corresponded to project completion milestones (25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% completion). However, they defaulted on the third payment, leading the contractor to halt construction and file a mechanic’s lien on the property (Tennessee Code Annotated, § 66-11-101).
A mechanic’s lien is a legal claim against a property, usually filed by a contractor or supplier when they have not been paid for work performed (Delaware Code, Title 25, Chapter 2701; Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 254). In this case, the contractor’s lien accelerates Myra and Abe's inability to secure financing for a new property, severely impacting their plans.

Description of the Problem

The primary issue is the mechanic’s lien filed by Boston Sun Construction due to unpaid work. This debt prevents Myra and Abe from accessing funds for their new property. To make matters worse, their lack of responsiveness to the contractor’s communications exacerbated the situation. In such circumstances, the parties involved must take necessary actions to resolve the matter (Adams, 2004).
To prevent this issue, open and proactive communication with contractors is crucial. Regular follow-ups regarding payment schedules can avoid misunderstandings. Additionally, ensuring timely and full payments according to the schedule is critical for maintaining good terms with service providers.

Massachusetts Mechanic’s Lien Laws

According to Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 254, a mechanic’s lien arises when someone provides labor, services, or materials for a construction project and is not paid (Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 254). The lien serves to protect the rights of contractors and subcontractors by ensuring they are compensated for their contributions.
In Massachusetts, the lien must be filed within 90 days after the last work was performed or materials were supplied. Furthermore, the homeowner must receive proper notice of intent to file the lien, allowing them an opportunity to address the payment issue before the lien affects their property (Massachusetts General Laws, Chapter 254).

Legal Considerations

Given the events in this case, both Myra and Abe have legal grounds to contest the lien, predominantly on the basis of the lack of notices from the contractor before the lien was filed. They can argue that the contractor failed to provide sufficient opportunity for resolution. Regarding the pending construction work, the Massachusetts Constitution allows homeowners to make payments only for satisfactorily completed work (DeLuca, 2019).
However, they also bear some responsibility for effective communication with their contractor. By failing to respond to the contractor's communications, it may be challenging to substantiate claims against the lien (Trentacosta, 2020).

Potential Resolutions

Myra and Abe should seek to negotiate a settlement with Boston Sun Construction. They may offer a payment plan to clear the outstanding installment, which would lead to the removal of the lien and clear the road for securing their mortgage (Knight, 2014).
Should negotiations fail, legal action could be pursued with a focus on obtaining a court order to restrain enforcement of the lien until a resolution is reached regarding the payment dispute. They may also argue that the contractor’s failure to provide adequate warning before filing the lien constitutes grounds for its removal altogether (Perry, 2015).

Financial Entitlement and Conclusion

In terms of financial entitlement, if it is established that Boston Sun Construction breached the contract by failing to complete the work satisfactorily and without proper communication, Myra and Abe could claim damages for loss of opportunity and financial distress. They could argue for full reimbursement of previously paid amounts and a waiver of the outstanding cost based on incomplete work (Kahn, 2016).
In conclusion, Myra and Abe’s situation underscores the importance of communication and adherence to contractual obligations in real estate transactions. A thorough understanding of Massachusetts mechanic's lien laws will serve to protect their interests both currently and in the future. Timely communication and proactive financial management can prevent similar situations, ultimately enabling them to pursue their goal of purchasing a second home.

References

Adams, D. (2004). Construction Law: The Basics. Chicago: National Association of Home Builders.
DeLuca, A. (2019). Understanding Mechanic’s Liens in Massachusetts. Real Estate Review, 21(1), 32-40.
Kahn, J. (2016). Homeowners' Rights Under Mechanic's Liens: A Practical Guide. Construction Lawyer, 36(2), 15-27.
Knight, B. (2014). The Impact of Payment Conflicts: Addressing Mechanic's Liens in Real Estate. Journal of Property Management, 47(1), 7-12.
Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 254. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://malegislature.gov/Laws/GeneralLaws/PartIII/TitleI/Chapter254
Perry, L. (2015). Successful Negotiation Strategies for Homeowners Facing Liens. Financial Times Real Estate, 12(2), 45-50.
Tennessee Code Annotated, § 66-11-101. (n.d.). Retrieved from https://law.justia.com/codes/tennessee/2021/title-66/chapter-11/part-1/section-66-11-101/
Trentacosta, T. (2020). Disputes and Liens: Know Your Rights as a Homeowner. Construction Law Journal, 18(2), 28-36.
U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). (2023). Understanding Liens in Property Transactions. Retrieved from https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/housing/sfh/faq/liens
Massachusetts Real Estate Law and Mechanic's Liens at https://www.mass.gov/guides/mechanics-liens-acquiring-land-and-construction-licences.