According to Mackie, the “greater goods” theodicy claims that there is more good
ID: 3489715 • Letter: A
Question
According to Mackie, the “greater goods” theodicy claims that there is more good in the world with some evil than there could be if there were no evil. What does he say is wrong with this reasoning? a. Since every greater good has a corresponding evil, the theodicy never ends b. This theodicy is not consistent with the claim that God is omnipotent c. Mackie does not claim that anything is wrong with the greater goods theodicy d. All of the above e. None of the aboveAccording to Mackie, the “greater goods” theodicy claims that there is more good in the world with some evil than there could be if there were no evil. What does he say is wrong with this reasoning? a. Since every greater good has a corresponding evil, the theodicy never ends b. This theodicy is not consistent with the claim that God is omnipotent c. Mackie does not claim that anything is wrong with the greater goods theodicy d. All of the above e. None of the above
According to Mackie, the “greater goods” theodicy claims that there is more good in the world with some evil than there could be if there were no evil. What does he say is wrong with this reasoning? a. Since every greater good has a corresponding evil, the theodicy never ends b. This theodicy is not consistent with the claim that God is omnipotent c. Mackie does not claim that anything is wrong with the greater goods theodicy d. All of the above e. None of the above
Explanation / Answer
The correct answer is a
Explanation : John. L. Mackie was an Australian philosopher. His theory of 'problem of evil' had many counter arguments. One of them were that 'there is more good in the world with some evil than there could be without any'. Mackie criticised this claim severely. He said that this means in order for some nth good there would some some mth evil. This summation would keep adding up leading to a never ending cycle of evil with no corresponding goodness to fight it as n>m. Therefore the correct answer is a.